FlashJobs logo
Let's talk

Pros and Cons of Gig Work vs Traditional Employment in Gig Economy

Table of Contents

Pros and Cons of Gig Work vs Traditional Employment in Gig Economy

Is the traditional 9-to-5 job becoming a thing of the past? Today, the gig economy is changing how we view work. Nearly 40% of Americans are in gig work, and in Asia, too, such as Malaysia, 4 million workers, 26% of the workforce, participated in gig work as of 2020. This change is here to stay. I’ve seen a big shift in how people view their careers. The gig economy offers great flexibility and control over work hours. But it also has its own set of challenges. As someone who has tried traditional and freelance jobs, I often wonder: How does this new work world compare to the old one?

gig work vs traditional work pros and cons

The typical gig worker is often older than you might think, at 43 years old. They usually have families and seek ways to balance work and life. This shift isn’t just for millennials dreaming of starting their own businesses. It’s about workers of all ages finding new ways to make a living. Remote jobs and flexible hours are big in the gig economy. Hence, the gig economy is a flexible way to find work. Gig workers value the quality of work over traditional qualifications. But this freedom comes with a catch. Gig workers often miss out on benefits like health insurance and retirement plans that come with traditional jobs.

Key Takeaways

  • 39% and 26% of the U.S. and Malaysia workforce have participated in gig work
  • Freelancers are becoming more skilled as gig work grows
  • Over half of caregivers rely on freelancing for income
  • 63% of freelancers report earning more than in traditional jobs
  • 47% of independent workers value schedule control
  • There are 53 million freelancers in the United States

The Gig Worker Experience

The gig economy has grown a lot in recent years. As a freelancer, I’ve seen how it’s changing our work life.

Who are gig workers?

Gig workers are people who work on short-term projects for extra cash. We’re a mix of part-timers and full-time freelancers. Most of us are 43 years old and have families to support.

Typical scene for traditional employment in the office

Typical gig economy jobs

Gig work covers many fields. I’ve done writing and graphic design. Other gigs include driving for rideshares, delivering food, and web development. Now, even skilled tradespeople are joining the gig economy.

Expansion of types of gig work into blue-collar jobs

The gig economy has expanded beyond food delivery and ride-hailing services to encompass various blue-collar jobs. This diversification offers more opportunities for workers seeking flexible employment in various industries. Some of the blue-collar gig jobs now available include:
  • Handyman services
  • Moving and packing assistance
  • Pet sitting and dog walking
  • Gardening and lawn care
  • Automotive repair and maintenance
  • Massage therapy
  • Courier and package delivery
  • Personal shopping
  • Product sampling and survey collection
  • Barista
  • Frontend F&B
  • Kitchen assistant
  • Cashier
  • Sales assistant
  • Stocker and stock associates
  • Warehouse and logistics tasks
  • Cleaning services
  • Home repair and maintenance
These diverse opportunities, available in many gig platforms such as FlashJobs, demonstrate that the gig economy is no longer limited to just a few sectors but has expanded to include a wide range of skilled and semi-skilled blue-collar work. This expansion allows workers to leverage their specific skills and interests while enjoying the flexibility of gig work. Our previous article talks of the Differences between Temp Work, On-Demand Work and Gig Work

Freelancers vs. traditional employees

Freelancers don’t get a steady paycheck or benefits like regular employees. We have to find our own work and handle our taxes. But we enjoy more flexibility and can earn more. About 70% of us love this flexibility.

Part-timers vs. freelancers

Part-time jobs offer set hours and some benefits. Freelancers work on projects and don’t have set hours or benefits. The gig economy is growing. By 2027, most U.S. workers will be part of it. Whether you’re thinking of freelancing full-time or just for extra cash, knowing about gig worker life is key in today’s job market.

Pros of Gig Work

Gig work offers exciting opportunities for those seeking career flexibility and autonomy. It provides unique advantages that traditional employment often can’t match.

Flexibility and Autonomy

As a gig worker, I enjoy the freedom to choose when and where I work. This flexibility lets me create a schedule that fits my lifestyle. I can work from home, at a coffee shop, or even while travelling. This level of autonomy is especially valuable for balancing work and personal commitments.

Flexibility, pros and cons of gig work

Diverse Work Opportunities

The gig economy offers a wide array of projects across various industries. I’ve had the chance to work on diverse projects, expanding my skill set and keeping my work interesting. This variety prevents boredom and helps me build a broad professional network.

Potential for Higher Earnings

Gig work often has the potential for higher earnings than traditional jobs. For instance, a freelance software developer can typically charge more per hour than a company-employed software engineer. I’ve found that setting my own rates and taking on multiple projects increases my income potential. Similarly, using the FlashJobs online gig platform, you can choose the time and hourly rates to improve your flexibility and earn more. In effect, FlashJobs will further shape the dynamic of the work market, where employers will pay more for gig workers when urgent needs arise. Gig work seekers will travel to areas to match the demand of employers looking for staff. The idea is to maximize the potential earnings of gig workers.

Work-Life Balance

The flexibility of gig work contributes significantly to achieving a better work-life balance. I can adjust my work hours to accommodate personal needs, pursue hobbies, or further my education. This balance leads to increased job satisfaction and overall well-being.
“Gig work allows me to be my own boss and create a career that aligns with my personal goals and values.”
While gig work comes with its challenges, the benefits of flexibility, diverse projects, higher earnings potential, and improved work-life balance make it an attractive option for many professionals in today’s evolving job market.

Cons of the Gig Economy

The gig economy offers flexibility, but it has its downsides. Job insecurity is a big issue for gig workers. With 1.3 million gig workers in the U.K., it’s important to understand these challenges.

Job Insecurity and Inconsistent Income

Gig workers often worry about when they’ll get paid. Unlike regular jobs, gigs don’t offer steady work, which can cause financial stress and anxiety. Only 25% of U.K. gig workers depend on it as their main income.

Lack of Benefits

One big issue with the gig economy is the lack of employee benefits. Gig workers don’t get healthcare, paid time off, or retirement plans. This can be tough during illness or financial trouble.

Self-employment Challenges

Gig workers must handle their taxes and work expenses on their own. While some costs can be deducted, they can be hard to manage. The Trades Union Congress says the U.K. loses £4 billion a year because of lost taxes and higher in-work benefits from gig work.

Skill Mismatch

Finding gigs that match your skills can be hard. Many gig workers struggle to find steady work in their field. This can lead to underemployment and frustration. Despite these challenges, the gig economy keeps growing. Workers should think about these downsides and benefits before joining the gig world.

Traditional Employment: A Comparison

I’ve noticed a change in the job market, but traditional employment is still strong. Let’s explore what it offers versus the gig economy.

Stability and Predictability

Traditional jobs are known for their stability. I can rely on a steady paycheck and set work hours. This predictability makes it easier to plan my life and budget.

Employee Benefits and Protections

Traditional jobs come with great benefits. You get health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off. These benefits offer a safety net not found in gig work.

Career Advancement Opportunities

Traditional employment often has clear paths for moving up. I’ve seen many companies offer training and promote from within. This gives me a chance to advance in my career.

Structured Work Environment

Traditional jobs have a structured work environment. I enjoy having a dedicated workspace and regular meetings with colleagues. This setup helps build teamwork and a strong company culture.
Aspect Traditional Employment Gig Economy
Income Stable, predictable Variable, unpredictable
Benefits Comprehensive package Limited or none
Career Growth Clear advancement paths Self-driven development
Work Environment Structured, office-based Flexible, often remote
The gig economy offers flexibility, but traditional employment gives a sense of security and structure. Many workers still prefer this. The choice between the two depends on personal preferences and career goals.

Advantages of Gig Work over Traditional Employment

Gig work has unique benefits that distinguish it from traditional jobs. It offers work freedom, skill development, and the chance to work from anywhere, which are hard to find in regular jobs.

Freedom to Choose Work

One big plus of gig work is choosing projects I like. This freedom lets me work on different projects and set my own schedule. In fact, 44% of U.S. freelancers make more money than in a regular job. This shows the earning potential of this flexible work.

Skill Development Across Industries

Gig work lets me work in various industries, which helps me grow my skills. With 26% of U.S. freelancers having a postgraduate degree, this is very valuable. It allows me to use and improve my skills in different fields.

Location Independence

Being able to work from anywhere is a big plus of gig work. This makes my work and personal life better balanced. Millennials, who make up 45% of the U.S. gig workforce, really like this flexibility.
Aspect Gig Work Traditional Employment
Work Selection Choose projects freely Assigned tasks
Skill Growth Diverse industry exposure Limited to a specific role
Location Work from anywhere Office-bound typically
Schedule Flexible hours Fixed work hours
The gig economy has grown from $6 billion to a projected $9.1 billion in the U.S. by 2023. It offers good pay with an average hourly rate of $44 for North American independent workers. Gig work is becoming more popular for many reasons. With the FlashJobs online platform, there’s a higher probability of earning extra hourly income when you can showcase your profile to employers. This includes part-time gig work other than the typical ride-hailing and food deliveries.

Disadvantages of Gig Work Compared to Traditional Jobs

Gig work is flexible but has big downsides compared to traditional jobs. I’ve seen many challenges that gig workers face today.

Career Limitations and Inconsistent Income

One big issue with gig work is the lack of clear career growth. Unlike regular jobs, gig work often doesn’t offer a clear path for moving up. This can lead to career limits and not growing in your job. Also, the income can be unpredictable. In some months, you might earn a lot, while in others, you might struggle to get by.

Social Isolation and Tax Responsibilities

Many gig jobs are done remotely, which can lead to feeling isolated. Without regular work hours, gig workers miss out on daily chats with coworkers. They also have to handle all their taxes by themselves. This means figuring out complex tax laws, saving for taxes, and planning their finances.

Platform Exploitation and Lack of Benefits

Many gig workers face being taken advantage of by online platforms that take big cuts from their pay. These platforms often focus on making more money than taking care of workers. Unlike regular employees, gig workers usually don’t get benefits like health insurance or retirement plans. This can make them financially unsure in the future.
Aspect Traditional Jobs Gig Work
Income Stability Regular paycheck Inconsistent income
Career Growth Structured advancement Limited opportunities
Social Interaction Daily workplace interactions Potential social isolation
Benefits Health insurance, retirement plans No employer-provided benefits
Tax Handling Traditional Employer manages taxes Self-managed tax responsibilities
While gig work offers flexibility, it’s important to think about these downsides before choosing a career.

Impact on Companies and Workers

The gig economy has changed how companies use gig workers. I’ve seen how companies are changing their workforce to stay ahead and save money.

How Businesses Utilize Gig Workers

Companies use gig workers for many reasons. They can easily grow or shrink their teams without the costs of full-time jobs, which allows them to adjust quickly to market changes.
Industry Gig Worker Percentage Primary Benefits
Transportation 36% On-demand service
Hospitality 25% Flexible accommodations
I.T. 20% Specialized skills

Changing Dynamics in the Workforce

The way we work is changing fast. Gig work is replacing old job models by combining gig and traditional jobs. This change requires new ways of managing and working together.

Balancing Gig and Traditional Workers

Finding a balance between gig and traditional workers is key. While 42% of gig workers may have unstable incomes, they offer special skills and flexibility. Companies must find ways to keep their teams together and save money. The gig economy has benefits and drawbacks. As companies adjust, they must consider how it will affect their future and work culture. The future of work will likely combine gig and traditional jobs.

Future Trends in the Gig Economy

I’ve been watching the gig economy grow rapidly over the past decade. The gig economy growth shows no signs of slowing down. In 2017, 55 million Americans were gig workers. That’s 34% of the U.S. workforce! By 2023, it’s expected to reach 43%.

Top 10 Countries with the Fastest Growing Earnings for Freelancers

Country Growth Percentage
USA 78%
United Kingdom 59%
Brazil 48%
Pakistan 47%
Ukraine 36%
Philippines 35%
India 29%
Bangladesh 27%
Russia 20%
Serbia 19%
The above is taken from “Gig Workers in Malaysia: A Review of Definition & Estimation.” However, there’s not enough information and research to indicate that a rise in gig work has reduced traditional work.

Growing Gig Workforce

Economic uncertainties often push more people into gig work. Industries like transport, tech, creative services, and healthcare are feeling the biggest impact. The economic impact of gig work is huge. In 2018, the global gig economy generated $204 billion!

Evolving Labor Laws,  Official Definitions and Court Cases

Labour law evolution is trying to keep up with this shift. Gig workers often lack health insurance, retirement plans, and paid leave. New laws aim to protect these workers while maintaining the flexibility that draws many to gig work. In July 2020, researchers from the UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose suggested a new way to think about gig workers. They said we should look at how much control the company has over the worker and how much the worker relies on the company. Some gig workers are independent, choosing their jobs and not depending on just one app or company. However, many others are what we might call “dependent contractors” rather than independent contractors.  These workers rely heavily on specific apps or platforms to get work, and the companies often control important parts of their freelance activities, such as finding work. This idea challenges the typical view of all gig workers as independent contractors. It suggests that we might need different rules for different types of gig work, depending on how much freedom and independence the workers have. In response to the growing gig economy, new laws have been created to address gig workers’ unique challenges. One notable example is California’s Assembly Bill 5 (AB5), which went into effect in 2020 and aimed to reclassify many gig workers as employees, entitling them to benefits and protections. Other jurisdictions have also introduced legislation to regulate gig work, such as the Self-Employment Social Security Act 2017 in Malaysia, which provides social security coverage for self-employed individuals in certain industries. As the gig economy evolves, more definitions of gig workers have emerged. The International Labour Organization (ILO) defines gig work as “short-term, temporary, or freelance work often facilitated by digital platforms.” The World Bank describes gig workers as “independent contractors, online platform workers, contract firm workers, on-call workers and temporary workers.” These definitions highlight the diverse nature of gig work and the need for comprehensive legal frameworks to address the unique challenges faced by this growing workforce segment. As the gig economy continues to expand, courts are also weighing in on the status of gig workers, often with varying interpretations. A significant court case in Malaysia in 2022 has set a precedent in the legal interpretation of gig workers’ definition. In this case, the High Court affirmed the Industrial Court’s decision, dismissing the appellant’s submission and ruling that e-hailing drivers are not employees but independent third-party contractors. This ruling highlights the ongoing challenges in defining and classifying gig workers within existing legal frameworks and underscores the need for more comprehensive and nuanced approaches to labour laws in the gig economy.

Technology’s Role

Technology in gig work is key. Digital platforms connect workers with jobs globally. This tech boom streamlines processes and enables remote work. It’s opening doors to a diverse, worldwide talent pool. This could lead to more innovation and a wider range of skills in the workforce. The future of work might be a mix of gig flexibility and traditional job stability. It’s an exciting time, full of opportunities and challenges for workers and businesses.

Making a Choice: Gig Work or Traditional Employment?

Choosing between gig work and traditional jobs is a big decision. It’s not the same for everyone. You must carefully think about your lifestyle, goals, and money needs.

Assessing Personal Preferences and Lifestyle

I look at what kind of work I like and how I like to spend my days. Do I do well with a set schedule, or do I prefer to have my own plan? Gig work gives a lot of, with 36% of workers now in the gig economy. This is great for fitting work around other parts of your life, like school or taking care of kids.

Evaluating Financial Goals and Stability Needs

Thinking about money is key when deciding. Gig work can be unpredictable and doesn’t always offer the same benefits as a regular job. Only 40% of gig workers get health insurance. But saving 25-30% of your gig earnings for taxes is smart. Some gig workers can even make more money than those with traditional jobs.

Considering Long-term Career Aspirations

My future career goals are important in this choice. Traditional jobs usually have clearer paths for moving up. But, the gig economy is growing fast – three times faster than the U.S. workforce. This could mean more chances to learn new skills and gain diverse experiences.
Factor Gig Work Traditional Employment
Flexibility High Low to Moderate
Income Stability Variable Stable
Benefits Limited Comprehensive
Career Advancement Self-Driven Structured
The choice between gig work and a traditional job depends on my own situation, how much risk I can take, and what I want to achieve in my career. It’s a choice that needs regular checking as the job market and my goals change.

Conclusion: Pros and Cons of Gig Work and Navigating the Modern Workforce

The modern workforce is changing fast. The gig economy and traditional jobs now mix, offering flexibility and stability. This change is big for everyone in the job world.

Balancing self-effort, flexibility and stability with extra income

The gig economy has changed how we earn extra money and gain new skills. McKinsey Global Institute says 30% of freelancers now earn most of their income this way. This shows how important finding a good work-life balance has become. Millennials, who make up 25% of gig workers, are finding ways to mix gig jobs with regular jobs, which helps them get more out of their lives. However, this responsibility requires more awareness of the downside of being an independent contractor. You will get less benefit if you are on your own compared to working in traditional employment. You need to take a more proactive role in understanding your rights as a partner in a working relationship so your rights are not further undermined. The short-term might be good, though you also need to be aware of the long-term prospects for yourself as a gig worker, such as retirement plans and insurance.

The future of work: A hybrid model?

Looking into the future, work might blend traditional and gig jobs together. Intuit’s 2020 Report says over 40% of workers could be in gig jobs by the next decade. This means we’ll need to be more flexible in how we work. As a journalist, I think this hybrid model could lead to better careers and a stronger workforce. It’s about finding the best parts of both worlds. The job world is changing fast, and it’s important for workers and employers to keep up. There are challenges like unstable income and different benefits. But, there are also big chances for growth and flexibility. Finding the right mix of gig and traditional jobs will help us navigate this new work landscape.

FAQ

What is the gig economy?

The gig economy involves people working short-term jobs, often on a freelance basis. They earn money through various short-term tasks, different from traditional full-time jobs.

Who are gig workers?

Gig workers make money through freelance or contract jobs. They can do everything from short tasks to long projects. This group includes people with many different skills and working on their own terms.

What are the advantages of gig work?

Gig work offers flexibility and the chance to choose your projects. You can earn more and have a better work-life balance. It also lets you develop skills across various industries and work from anywhere.

What are the disadvantages of gig work compared to traditional jobs?

The downsides include job insecurity and no benefits like health insurance. You might face unstable income and have to handle taxes and expenses yourself. There’s also less chance for career growth and social interaction at work.

How does traditional employment differ from gig work?

Traditional jobs offer stability, predictable pay, benefits, and a structured work environment. However, they might limit flexibility and the chance to try different things.

How do businesses utilize gig workers?

Companies use gig workers to save money and be more flexible. They can easily adjust their workforce without the costs of full-time staff. But, they might struggle with quality control and team culture.

What are the future trends in the gig economy?

The gig economy is set to grow, especially in tough economic times. Laws are changing to better protect gig workers, and technology is key in connecting workers with jobs worldwide.

How can individuals choose between gig work and traditional employment?

Choosing depends on what you want for your life and career. Consider how much you value flexibility versus stability, as well as your financial and career goals.

Source Links

Facebook
Twitter
Email
Print
Picture of Zakir Jaafar
Zakir Jaafar
Zakir Jaafar co-founded FlashJobs, an online platform that connects small businesses with part-time and gig workers. Currently, he also manages UVCC Sdn Bhd, a venture capital builder in Kuala Lumpur, which is part of the VC firm Origgin.com. As a startup coach, Zakir works with two university accelerators: UMDT at the University of Malaya (UM) and InnoXcelerate at the University Kebangsaan of Malaysia (UKM). Previously, he coached startups in the MySIAP Program under Yayasan Innovasi Malaysia and InnoHub Accelerator at University Putra Malaysia (UPM). Earlier in his career, Zakir led the Technology Transfer and Commercialization units at two major Malaysian universities. He mentored over 100 startups, with twelve of them raising more than RM13 million and successfully licensing their intellectual property to the universities. Zakir's diverse experience includes being the franchisor for 1901 Hot Dogs, overseeing 105 franchise outlets. This role provided him with valuable insights into managing small businesses and working with part-time/gig staffs. He holds a Master's degree in Economics and Finance from Loughborough University, adding academic credibility to his practical business expertise.

Newsletter

Sign up our newsletter to get update information, news and free insight.

Latest Post

Sign up our newsletter to get update information, news and free insight.

FlashJobs logo
Facebook-f Instagram Linkedin Whatsapp

Our Solutions

For Employers

For Gig Workers

About Us

Contact Us

Ideas & Feedback

Insights

FlashJobs App

FlashJobs Inc. © 2024, All rights reserved.